http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/02/what-george-will-should-have-written/langswitch_lang/im#comment-113891
Written by fatih al-farahat in
Gavin Schmidt, Real Climate, responds to RickA's lack of knowledge of past Arctic temperatures
Links Global Warming
Popular Posts
-
by Andy Coghlan, NewScientist Environment , 20 August 2008 FEELING blue about climate change? Don't despair. Psychologists say they can ...
-
Glen Hiemstra, who has been my futurist mentor at Futurist.com, has offered to post here as well from time to time. Like me, he is concerne...
-
This item is important for acouple of reasons. Firstly itestablishes the Mycenaean period in Greece as 1600 BC through 1100 BCas the prese...
-
by Clifford Krauss, New York Times , May 27, 2008 HOUSTON — The Rockefeller family built one of the great American fortunes by supplying t...
-
The bee story continues with the UK now doing acomplete review of the neonicotinoid situation. It is reminiscent of the foot-dragging tha...
-
It is always much more telling when a scientific leader is advancing his stature by calling everyone out on the global warming hypothesis. ...
-
The bee story continues with the UK now doing acomplete review of the neonicotinoid situation. It is reminiscent of the foot-dragging tha...
-
Earth Observatory , NASA News Archive, May 7, 2008 SOLAR VARIABILITY: STRIKING A BALANCE WITH CLIMATE CHANGE The sun has powered almost ever...
-
Geology , February 2009, Vol. 37, No. 2, 175 – 178; doi:10.1130/G25329A.1 © 2009 Geological Society of America Multicentennial megadrought ...
-
This is a quick review of the current thinking on the idea of a warp drive and its application in metamaterials where it may have practical ...
Blog Archive
-
►
2010
(3220)
- December (224)
- November (402)
- October (532)
- September (548)
- August (403)
- July (399)
- June (196)
- May (96)
- April (96)
- March (86)
- February (101)
- January (137)
-
▼
2009
(1837)
- December (344)
- November (203)
- October (160)
- September (172)
- August (125)
- July (195)
- June (131)
- May (69)
- April (73)
- March (90)
- February (150)
- January (125)
-
►
2008
(535)
- December (57)
- November (16)
- October (79)
- September (39)
- August (69)
- July (67)
- June (38)
- May (43)
- April (53)
- March (42)
- February (14)
- January (18)
Feedjit
this blog learn to you all people in the world to keep our earth
Powered by Blogger.


2 March 2009 at 1:28 PM
#99 – Gavin’s in-line question:
[Response: What data are you looking at here? I know of no such sea ice data set that would demonstrate this. – gavin]
You are making my point.
We don’t have very high quality data for the Arctic much before 1978.
We have lower quality data which make this point.
Jones et al. data set shows the temperature in the Arctic higher in the 1930s than currently.
The Arctic Climate Impact Assessment, p. 52, talks about the temperature in the Arctic over the last millennium and seems to support several rises and falling trends in the Arctic over that time period.
Roald Amundsen completed the first sailing of the Northwest passage in 1903–1906 – so I assume it was pretty warm in the arctic then (I admit this one is implied).
The point is that the temperature has been higher in the Arctic in the past – more than once even – so what is different about today than those other times?
[Response: Thank you. You clearly demonstrate that you have no data that shows that sea ice was equally low in the 1930s. The little data there is (from ship reports mainly) indicate that this was not actually the case. If you wanted to use an example where the prevailing data did suggest less ice then than now, you’d have to go back to the Early Holocene (say 8 to 6,000 years ago). There are beach deposits and large faunal remains in what are now frozen inlets across the Archipelago and northern Greenland. However, why that happened then is easier to understand – the orbit of the Earth at that time meant that summertime solar irradiance in the Northern Hemisphere was greater than it is now, and summer temperatures were higher as a result. This is not therefore the cause of today’s changes, but the example does serve to indicate that sea ice is indeed sensitive to the radiative balance. It is thus not surprising that sea ice is retreating when we have our own radiative perturbation underway. – gavin]