Dear Readers,
Sorry about yet another post on Viscount Monckton, but this transcript is interesting. More interesting is the funding the group Americans for Prosperty (AFP) receives from Koch Industries, the largest private energy company in the U.S. Koch Industries also funds the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI) whose biggest mouthpiece is Fred Singer (tells everyone that CO2 is wonderful, and so were cigarettes for that matter).
Viscount Monckton calls young climate activists 'Hitler Youth'
Christopher Monckton berates a group of young activists for interrupting a meeting of climate sceptics in Copenhagen, calling them 'Nazis' and 'Hitler Youth'
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ne-X_vFWMlw
The Guardian, December 11, 2009
When Christopher Monckton, the hereditary third Viscount Monckton of Brenchley, attended an Americans for Prosperity meeting in Copenhagen on Wednesday night that was interrupted by chanting youth delegates, he was reportedly furious. But no one expected him to go back and berate them.
Yesterday he ambushed a small group of students from the non-profit SustainUS inside the Bella centre. One of them texted her friends for help. Several arrived, including Ben Wessel, a 20-year-old activist from Middlebury College, Vermont.
Monckton then repeatedly called them "Nazis" and "Hitler Youth". When Wessel told him that his family were Jewish, Monckton carried on.
"I was so surprised," Wessel said today. "I hoped to have a more civil conversation with the man. It's fine that we have differences, but it's not okay to pull out such hateful language."
Here's the full transcript of the exchange between Wessel and Monckton:
Ben Wessel: [of the Sustain US youth delegation] First of all my name is Ben [sticks his hand out to shake].Link: http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/blog/2009/dec/11/monckton-calls-activists-hitler-youth
Monckton: No, no. I'm not going to shake the hand of Hitler Youth. I'm sorry.
Wessel: Sir, as a Jew I'm not really sure how I should take that.
Monckton: I'll tell you how you should take it. You should take it.
Wessel: My grandparents escaped the Nazis growing up in Germany.
Monckton: Because of the biofuel scam, world food prices have doubled. That it because of the global warming scare, which you won't look at the science of. As a result of that, millions are dying in third world countries because food prices have doubled because of the biofuel scam, because of the global warming scare.
And you people don't care. And until you start caring I will call you Hitler Youth if you ever again interrupt any meeting at which I am present, where we are trying to have a private conversation.
Monckton: [talking over everyone] Tough luck. So now you know what it looks like when you do robotic chants of the sort which the Hitler Youth used to do in Copenhagen when they occupied this city.
Unidentified youth: Sir, you just need to grow up!
Monckton: I have cited scientific papers ... So I think you should all just chill out and accept that if you ever behave like that again I will call you that again in public. You're already now known and your faces around the world are known as members of the Hitler Youth, or people who do as much damage to the poor as the Hitler Youth did. And you have got to accept that if you are not willing to take it, then you shouldn't give it. And don't you go around invading people's meetings again.
Thank you very much. Good day to you all.
[Monckton walks away and Wessel follows]
Wessel: I think it's good to not try and drown out other people's opinions and I do agree with that.
Monckton: That's what you did. That's what you did. That is what the Hitler Youth did. And if you behave like the Hitler Youth, I'll call you what you are - Hitler Youth.
And you'll like or it or you'll lump it.
Wessel: Okay. I'll let you know how I feel about that personally in a second.
Monckton: Tough ....
Wessel: I would like to tell you though, that for as long as I've been alive ... the past 20 years, the science has been settled.
The two debate the science of anthropogenic climate change.
Wessel: I would like to give you my card, if you would like to discuss this.
Monckton: I do not wants the cards of the Hitler Youth. No.
Wessel: Sir, as a Jew, again ... I think ... this is absurd and I'm just getting a little frustrated ...
Monckton: I have just seen what has happened for instance in Haiti because of people like you, shrieking in public meetings and propagandising so as to try and push an agenda which has nothing to do with looking after the poor of this planet, who are now dying in large numbers of starvation. Because people like you act just as those they were - the Hitler Youth. So I will call you what you are and you will like it or lump it. And don't you dare ever invade any meeting of mine again and behave in that childish, boonish, Hitler-ish fashion. Do I make myself clear?
Post a Comment