Showing posts with label Water shortage. Show all posts

The Guardian: Growing pressure on water supplies affecting one in five global businesses


Growing pressure on water supplies affecting one in five global businesses

Survey reveals drought, shortages, flooding and rising prices are damaging companies in water-intensive industries

Bluetongue brewery in Australia, SABMiller
The Bluetongue brewery in Australia. Companies most at risk are in the food and drink, tobacco, and metals and mining sectors, says the report. Photograph: SABMiller

At least one in five of the companies using the largest amounts of waterin the world is already experiencing damage to their business fromdrought and other shortages, flooding, and rising prices.
The wide scope of commercial problems posed by growing pressure on global water supplies and changing weather patterns is revealed by a survey of the 302 biggest companies in the most water-intensive sectors, across 25 countries.
The study was commissioned by the increasingly influential Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP), which conducts an annual study of what companies are doing to measure and reduce greenhouse gas emissions on behalf of investors holding US$16trillion (£9.9tr) of assets.
About half the companies responded to the water survey, of whom 39% said they were already experiencing "detrimental impacts". In answer to a separate question, about half said the risks to their businesses were "current or near term" - in the next one to five years - a sample likely to have significant crossover with those already reporting problems.
Companies most at risk are in the food and drink, tobacco, and metals and mining sectors, says the first CDP Water Disclosure report. Other concerns listed were fines and litigation for pollution.
Marcus Norton, who headed the report, said companies that replied to the survey were more likely to have taken action to address water issues affecting their business, but he was still "impressed" by the replies: 96% were aware of potential problems, and two-thirds have somebody responsible for water issues at board or executive committee level.
Of the companies which did not reply, not all would be ignoring the problems, but Norton hoped in following years more companies would show they take the issue "seriously".
"I don't think this is an issue of the price of water increasing even 10-fold, which I think in many cases it will," he added. "For me it's about building resilience to and avoiding catastrophic damage from water scarcity and physical risks. If you run out of water you can't operate. We have seen floods in China and Pakistan cause hundreds of billions of dollars of damage."
Companies that ignore water dangers "pose a risk to investments", said Anne Kvam, head of corporate governance of Norges Bank Investment Management, a lead sponsor of the report.
The report, written by London-based consultancy Environmental Resource Management, names six companies showing "best practice" as mining giant Anglo American, consumer group Colgate-Palmolive, auto maker Ford, US utility PG&E, and engineers GE and Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing. This was not intended to suggest the named corporations were the top six, only that subjectively they were "good examples", said Norton.
A major report, Charting Our Water Future, commissioned by NestlĂ© and brewer SAB Miller among others last year, calculated by 2030 global water demand would outstrip supply by 40%, with shortages in some parts of the world much more severe than others, but also claimed existing management and technology could cut water use and boost supply enough to close the gap.
NestlĂ© chairman, Peter Brabeck-Letmathe, previously warned water is a greater threat than climate change, and called for significant rises in water prices to pressure big users to be more efficient.

Link:  http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/nov/12/water-supplies-global-businesses

Measuring the meltdown. With global warming hitting the Tibetan plateau hard, scientists gather to plan an international research campaign to understand and mitigate changes at the 'third pole'

Measuring the meltdown

With global warming hitting the Tibetan plateau hard, scientists gather to plan an international research campaign to understand and mitigate changes at the 'third pole'

More than a billion people rely on drinking water fed by Himalayan glaciers such as Khumbu in Nepal. This supply could be at risk unless glacial retreat is stopped.More than a billion people rely on drinking water fed by Himalayan glaciers such as Khumbu in Nepal. This supply could be at risk unless glacial retreat is stopped.J. BENDIKSEN/MAGNUM PHOTOS

Cold, remote and threatened by global warming: the description applies not only to the North and South Poles, but also to a region of more than five million square kilometres, centred on the Tibetan plateau and the Himalayas, that researchers call the third pole (see Nature 454, 393–396, 2008). After the Arctic and the Antarctic, the region has Earth's largest store of ice, in more than 46,000 glaciers and vast expanses of permafrost. Yet it is much less studied than its high-latitude counterparts, even though many more lives depend on it.

The third pole is also known as Asia's water tower, because its glaciers feed the continent's largest rivers, which sustain 1.5 billion people across ten countries. Those glaciers are melting fast, filling lakes that can overflow and flood valleys. Yet little is known about how climate change is unfolding there. To attempt to rectify this, Third Pole Environment (TPE), an international programme led by the Chinese Academy of Sciences' Institute of Tibetan Plateau Research (ITP) in Beijing, held its second workshop last month in Kathmandu. Researchers in the region laid plans to fill the knowledge gap, and discussed findings that add to the urgency.

"Everyone is doing important work across the region, but it is unclear how they fit together," says Yao Tandong, director of the ITP and chairman of the TPE science committee, which helped to organize the workshop. "The only way forward is for the international community to work together to assess the risks associated with climate change," he says.

As the region's population booms, the top priority of researchers is to understand the status and fate of glaciers that are a vital source of drinking water. Last year, a claim in the 2007 report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) that Himalayan glaciers could disappear by 2035 turned out to be an error (see Nature 463, 276-277; 2010). But participants at the workshop argued that the IPCC's broader concern about the rapid loss of Himalayan glacier ice was correct. "There is no doubt that many of the glaciers in the region are retreating fast," says Baldev Raj Arora, former director of the Wadia Institute of Himalayan Geology in Dehradun, India.

But it is not clear exactly how fast, or how this will affect water resources, because there is no glacier inventory for the entire region. Taken alone, satellite studies offer only a rough estimate of glaciated area, and remoteness, high altitudes and harsh weather conditions hamper measurement from the ground.
The evidence that is available is telling. Using a combination of satellite and ground measurements, a team led by Liu Shiyin, a glaciologist at the Chinese Academy of Sciences' Cold and Arid Regions Environmental and Engineering Research Institute in Lanzhou, has just completed the second Chinese national glacier inventory, documenting some 24,300 glaciers and recording characteristics such as their locations, lengths and surface areas. It shows that the total surface area of glaciers has decreased by 17% and that many have disappeared since the last inventory began, roughly 30 years ago.

To get a better estimate of such changes, researchers have also measured the ice volume and mass balance of representative glaciers in various parts of the Himalayas. Such arduous studies, often at altitudes above 5,000 metres, show that "the impact of climate change on some Himalayan glaciers is much worse than previously thought," says Tian Lide, a glaciologist at the ITP. The expansive Kangwure glacier on the northern slope of Mount Xixiabangma in southern Tibet, for instance, has lost nearly half of its ice since the 1970s, and its average thickness has decreased by 7.5 metres.

Most of the glaciers in the Indian Himalayas that have been studied in detail are also losing mass, says Arora. Across the third pole, "regional anomalies exist, but the balance of evidence certainly points towards a trend of fast retreat," agrees Lonnie Thompson, a glaciologist at Ohio State University in Columbus and a co-chairman of the TPE science committee.

Carbon toll

One cause of the retreat is the growing amount of sooty 'black carbon' made by fossil-fuel and biomass burning. Xu Baiqing, an environment scientist at the ITP, measured 50 years' worth of black-carbon levels in ice cores from five glaciers in various parts of the Himalayas, and found increased emissions since the 1990s, coinciding with rapid industrial growth in the region. Angela Marinoni, a climate scientist at the Institute of Atmospheric Sciences and Climate in Bologna, Italy, and her colleagues found high concentrations of aerosols, including black carbon, above 5,000 metres in the Nepalese Himalayas, which caused significant atmospheric warming. They calculate that deposition of black carbon could increase snow and ice melting of a typical Himalayan glacier by 12–34%, by reducing its ability to reflect light.

As a consequence, glacial lakes are getting larger and more numerous, causing more floods. A study led by Yongwei Sheng, an ecologist at the University of California, Los Angeles, shows that the area of such lakes on the plateau has increased by 26% since the 1970s, with a devastating effect on surrounding pastures. Outbursts of glacial lakes have caused more than 40 floods in the Himalayas since the 1950s, and more are likely in the coming decades, says Pradeep Mool, a remote-sensing specialist at the International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD) in Kathmandu. An ICIMOD survey listed more than 20,200 glacial lakes in the region; two hundred are "potentially dangerous" and need close monitoring and an early warning system, says Mool.

So far, scientists trying to forecast the glaciers' future have had little to go on. For one thing, says Thompson, "Glaciers respond to climate differently depending on their size, altitude distribution, surface area, debris cover and valley characteristics." And little is known about how climate is changing across the third pole.

Yang Kun, a climate scientist at the ITP, found that many satellite-based measurements of Earth's radiation budget — the balance of incoming solar radiation and outgoing heat — did not work well at the third pole's high elevations, because instruments are typically calibrated and verified against ground-truth data from the lowlands. They can be corrected using field measurements, but across the region, only 16 weather stations lie above 5,000 metres.

Investigators can't rely on climate models, either. Using data from the only weather station at 8,000 metres, on the South Col pass between mounts Everest and Lhotse, Kenichi Ueno, a climate scientist at the University of Tsukuba, Japan, showed that global climate models do not predict moisture and radiation flux well at such high altitude, especially in hot weather or monsoon season. "If you want to know how climate affects glaciers, such details are crucial," he says. "It's extremely important to have more high-altitude observations across the region."

A joint endeavour

The TPE science committee will soon draft a research programme to document the effects of climate change on glaciers, permafrost, water resources, biodiversity and people. The plan, to be finalized by autumn 2011, will call for joint expeditions to the Himalayas and the Tibetan plateau, and for multidisciplinary research stations across the region, to cover key geological areas and climate regimes as well as important river and lake basins. Once costs have been defined, the committee will seek support from national and international funding agencies.

The most important part of the plan is a common data repository, says Volker Mosbrugger, director of Senckenberg World of Biodiversity, a coalition of research institutes and museums in Frankfurt, Germany, and another co-chairman of the TPE science committee. But national rivalries may stand in the way, especially when the shared data concern water resources. "Whether there can be a central database up and running will determine whether the programme can move beyond its rhetoric," says Gregory Greenwood, director of the Mountain Research Initiative at the University of Bern. "This will be a great challenge."

The committee will draft a policy to be negotiated between countries interested in the programme, letting scientists share information but leave out data deemed politically sensitive. "Without working together and pooling data from across the third pole," says Yao, "comprehensive understanding of climate impact and feedback mechanisms would be impossible." 

Scathing review by the Planning Assessment Commission found that society would be better off if the coal remained in the ground, rejecting mine proposed by BHP Billiton near Sydney


Green win signals shift in mine approvals


by Ben Cubby, The Sydney Morning Herald, October 28, 2010
[Canadian and U.S. readers -- this is the kind of effort that we need in North America!]
BHP Billiton has shelved plans for a vast new coal mine under a conservation area south of Sydney, after a scathing review by the state's Planning Assessment Commission found that society would be better off if the coal remained in the ground.
The findings signal a change of direction for the state's mining approval process, with the commission also deciding that remediation by the company would not be able to make up for the environmental damage it would cause.
The project had been expected to dig up $60 billion worth of coal over the next 30 years.
The BHP Billiton subsidiary Illawarra Coal has put forward a new plan that will allow the 6200-hectare Dharawal State Conservation Area south-east of Campbelltown to remain undisturbed, and also excludes some sensitive water catchments near the township of Appin.
The government's commission analysed the mine's benefits in terms of jobs, economic activity and company profits and found that they did not outweigh the public benefit of having pristine bushland and water catchments close to Sydney.
''So while protection of the significant natural features would involve lower mine profitability, it is likely that society as a whole would gain more from the environmental protection recommended than it would lose in terms of foregone profits,'' its report said.
Although the company offered engineering solutions to some of the surface cracking and water pollution that it expected to cause, the commission decided that ''remediation cannot be considered at this time to be an alternative to prevention where the functionality of water-dependent natural features is an objective''.
It is ''no longer a viable proposition for mining to cause more than negligible damage to pristine or near-pristine waterways in drinking water catchments'', it said.
BHP Billiton had previously told the Herald the financial viability of the entire project hinged on being able to mine under the conservation area.
It said yesterday the revised proposal would still provide more than 2600 jobs in the region, and generate $200 million in household income.
"Reflecting changes in community expectations, Illawarra Coal has a strong track record of demonstrated commitment to the environment, being the first to move its longwall mining away from rivers, and our [new proposal] is a further reflection of this," said the project's manager of sustainable development, John Brannon.
The Total Environment Centre, which has been campaigning against mining in Sydney's drinking water catchment, said the decisions were a ''new benchmark''.
''It's clear the original proposal was unacceptable on environmental and economic grounds and that the reliance on so-called remediation is a myth,'' said Mr Angel.
''The panel makes it clear it is not acceptable to have more than negligible damage … . BHP's recognition of the force of these arguments is welcomed.''
The commission identified a problem with allowing mining companies to decide which natural features in their targeted areas should be granted ''special significance," a status that can accord them extra protection. It noted that BHP Billiton's proposal found one area of possible special significance in the entire mining zone -- the Nepean River.
''None of the other 46 streams …none of the 226 upland swamps, none of the 634 cliffs …and none of the 632 Aboriginal heritage sites in the study area succeeded in crossing the proponent's threshold for special significance,'' the report said, concluding there was ''an element of subjectivity'' in BHP's plan.
A hydrologist who gave evidence during the inquiry, Ann Young, said many of the swamps would have been destroyed.

Water -- The New Oil: Should private companies control our most precious natural resource? (Newsweek)


The New Oil

Should private companies control our most precious natural resource?

Ethan Miller / Getty Images
Click to view a gallery about how we're losing our lakes.
Losing Our Lakes: Precious Resources at Risk
Sitka, Alaska, is home to one of the world’s most spectacular lakes. Nestled into a U-shaped valley of dense forests and majestic peaks, and fed by snowpack and glaciers, the reservoir, named Blue Lake for its deep blue hues, holds trillions of gallons of water so pure it requires no treatment. The city’s tiny population—fewer than 10,000 people spread across 5,000 square miles—makes this an embarrassment of riches. Every year, as countries around the world struggle to meet the water needs of their citizens, 6.2 billion gallons of Sitka’s reserves go unused. That could soon change. In a few months, if all goes according to plan, 80 million gallons of Blue Lake water will be siphoned into the kind of tankers normally reserved for oil—and shipped to a bulk bottling facility near Mumbai. From there it will be dispersed among several drought-plagued cities throughout the Middle East. The project is the brainchild of two American companies. One, True Alaska Bottling, has purchased the rights to transfer 3 billion gallons of water a year from Sitka’s bountiful reserves. The other, S2C Global, is building the water-processing facility in India. If the companies succeed, they will have brought what Sitka hopes will be a $90 million industry to their city, not to mention a solution to one of the world’s most pressing climate conundrums. They will also have turned life’s most essential molecule into a global commodity.
The transfer of water is nothing new. New York City is supplied by a web of tunnels and pipes that stretch 125 miles north into the Catskills Mountains; Southern California gets its water from the Sierra Nevada Mountains and the Colorado River Basin, which are hundreds of miles to the north and west, respectively. The distance between Alaska and India is much farther, to be sure. But it’s not the distance that worries critics. It’s the transfer of so much water from public hands to private ones. “Water has been a public resource under public domain for more than 2,000 years,” says James Olson, an attorney who specializes in water rights. “Ceding it to private entities feels both morally wrong and dangerous.”
Everyone agrees that we are in the midst of a global freshwater crisis. Around the world, rivers, lakes, and aquifers are dwindling faster than Mother Nature can possibly replenish them; industrial and household chemicals are rapidly polluting what’s left. Meanwhile, global population is ticking skyward. Goldman Sachs estimates that global water consumption is doubling every 20 years, and the United Nations expects demand to outstrip supply by more than 30 percent come 2040.
Purestock-Getty Images
100 Places to Remember Before They Disappear
100 Places To Remember
Proponents of privatization say markets are the best way to solve that problem: only the invisible hand can bring supply and demand into harmony, and only market pricing will drive water use down enough to make a dent in water scarcity. But the benefits of the market come at a price. By definition, a commodity is sold to the highest bidder, not the customer with the most compelling moral claim. As the crisis worsens, companies like True Alaska that own the rights to vast stores of water (and have the capacity to move it in bulk) won’t necessarily weigh the needs of wealthy water-guzzling companies like Coca-Cola or NestlĂ© against those of water-starved communities in Phoenix or Ghana; privately owned water utilities will charge what the market can bear, and spend as little as they can get away with on maintenance and environmental protection. Other commodities are subject to the same laws, of course. But with energy, or food, customers have options: they can switch from oil to natural gas, or eat more chicken and less beef. There is no substitute for water, not even Coca-Cola. And, of course, those other things don’t just fall from the sky on whoever happens to be lucky enough to be living below. “Markets don’t care about the environment,” says Olson. “And they don’t care about human rights. They care about profit.”
In the developed world—America especially—it’s easy to take water for granted. Turn on any tap, and it comes rushing out, clean and plentiful, even in the arid Southwest, where the Colorado River Basin is struggling through its 11th year of drought; in most cities a month’s supply still costs less than premium cable or a generous cell-phone plan. Many of us have no idea where our water comes from, let alone who owns it. In fact, most of us would probably agree that water is too precious for anybody to own. But the rights to divert water—from a river or lake or underground aquifer—are indeed sellable commodities; so too are the plants and pipes that process that water and deliver it to our taps. And as demand outstrips supply, those commodities are set to appreciate precipitously. According to a 2009 report by the World Bank, private investment in the water industry is set to double in the next five years; the water-supply market alone will increase by 20 percent.
Unlike the villain in James Bond’s Quantum of Solace who hatched a secret plot to monopolize Bolivia’s fresh-water supply, the real water barons cannot be reduced to a simple archetype. They include a diverse array of buyers and sellers—from multinational water giants like Suez and Veolia that together deliver water to some 260 million taps around the world, to wildcatter oil converts like T. Boone Pickens who wants to sell the water under his Texas Panhandle ranch to thirsty cities like Dallas. “The water market has become much more sophisticated in the last two decades,” says Clay Landry, director of WestWater Research, a consulting firm that specializes in water rights. “It’s gone from parochial transactions—back-of-the-truck, handshake--type deals—to a serious market with increasingly serious players.”
Eventually, Olson worries, every last drop will be privately controlled. And when that happens, the world will find itself divided along a new set of boundaries: water haves on one side, water have-nots on the other. The winners (Canada, Alaska, Russia) and losers (India, Syria, Jordan) will be different from those of the oil conflicts of the 20th century, but the bottom line will be much the same: countries that have the means to exploit large reserves will prosper. The rest will be left to fight over ever-shrinking reserves. Some will go to war.
Until recently, water privatization was an almost exclusively Third World issue. In the late 1990s the World Bank infamously required scores of impoverished countries—most notably Bolivia—to privatize their water supplies as a condition of desperately needed economic assistance. The hope was that markets would eliminate corruption and big multinationals would invest the resources needed to bring more water to more people. By 2000, Bolivian citizens had taken to the streets in a string of violent protests. Bechtel—the multinational corporation that had leased their pipes and plants—had more than doubled water rates, leaving tens of thousands of Bolivians who couldn’t pay without any water whatsoever. The company said price hikes were needed to repair and expand the dilapidated infrastructure. Critics insisted they served only to maintain unrealistic profit margins. Either way, the rioters sent the companies packing; by 2001, the public utility had resumed control.
These days, global water barons have set their sights on a more appealing target: countries with dwindling water supplies and aging infrastructure, but better economies than Bolivia’s. “These are the countries that can afford to pay,” says Olson. “They’ve got huge infrastructure needs, shrinking water reserves, and money.”
Nowhere is this truer than China. As the water table under Beijing plummets, wells dug around the city must reach ever-greater depths (nearly two thirds of a mile or more, according to a recent World Bank report) to hit fresh water. That has made water drilling more costly and water contracts more lucrative. Since 2000, when the country opened its municipal services to foreign investment, the number of private water utilities has skyrocketed. But as private companies absorb water systems throughout the country, the cost of water has risen precipitously. “It’s more than most families can afford to pay,” says Ge Yun, an economist with the Xinjiang Conservation Fund. “So as more water goes private, fewer people have access to it.”
In the U.S., federal funds for repairing water infrastructure—most of which was built around the same time that Henry Ford built the first Model T—are sorely lacking. The Obama administration has secured just $6 billion for repairs that the EPA estimates will cost $300 billion. Meanwhile, more than half a million pipes burst every year, according to the American Water Works Association, and more than 6 billion gallons of water are lost to leaky pipes. In response to the funding gap, hundreds of U.S. cities—including Pittsburgh, Chicago, and Santa Fe, N.M.—are now looking to privatize. On its face, the move makes obvious sense: elected officials can use the profits from water sales to balance city budgets, while simultaneously offloading the huge cost of repairing and expanding infrastructure—not to mention the politically unpopular necessity of raising water rates to do so—to companies that promise both jobs and economy-stimulating profits.
Of course, the reality doesn’t always meet that ideal. “Because water infrastructure is too expensive to allow multiple providers, the only real competition occurs during the bidding process,” says Wenonah Hauter, executive director of the nonprofit, antiprivatization group Food and Water Watch. “After that, the private utility has a virtual monopoly. And because 70 to 80 percent of water and sewer assets are underground, municipalities can have a tough time monitoring a contractor’s performance.” According to some reports, private operators often reduce the workforce, neglect water conservation, and shift the cost of environmental violations onto the city. For example, when two Veolia-operated plants spilled millions of gallons of sewage into San Francisco Bay, at least one city was forced to make multimillion-dollar upgrades to the offending sewage plant. (Veolia has defended its record.)
Even as many U.S. cities look toward ceding their water infrastructure to private interests, others are waging expensive legal battles to get out of such contracts. In 2009 Camden, N.J., sued United Water (an American subsidiary of the French giant Suez) for $29 million in unapproved payments, high unaccounted-for water losses, poor maintenance, and service disruptions. In Milwaukee a state audit found that the same company violated its contract by shutting down sewage pumps to save money; the move resulted in billions of gallons of raw sewage spilling into Lake Michigan. And in Gary, Ind., which canceled its contract with United Water after 12 years, critics say privatization more than doubled annual operating costs. “It ends up being a roundabout way to tax people,” Hauter says. “Only it’s worse than a tax because they don’t spend the money maintaining the system.”
Representatives of United Water point out that 95 percent of its contracts are in fact renewed and say that a few bad examples don’t tell the whole story. “We are dealing with facilities that were designed and built at the end of World War II,” says United Water CEO Bertrand Camus. “We have plenty of horror stories on our side, too.” The Gary facility, to take one example, went private only after the EPA forced the public utility to find a more experienced operator to solve a range of problems. “Individual municipalities don’t have the expertise to employ all the new technology to meet the new standards,” Camus says. “We do.”
The bottom line is this: that water is essential to life makes it no less expensive to obtain, purify, and deliver, and does nothing to change the fact that as supplies dwindle and demand grows, that expense will only increase. The World Bank has argued that higher prices are a good thing. Right now, no public utility anywhere prices water based on how scarce it is or how much it costs to deliver, and that, privatization proponents argue, is the root cause of such rampant overuse. If water costs more, they say, we will conserve it better.
The main problem with this argument is what economists call price inelasticity: no matter what water costs, we still need it to survive. So beyond trimming nonessential uses like lawn maintenance, car washing, and swimming pools, consumers really can’t reduce water consumption in proportion to rate increases. “Free-market theory works great for discretionary consumer purchases,” says Hauter. “But water is not like other commodities—it’s not something people can substitute or choose to forgo.” Dozens of studies have found that even with steep rate hikes, consumers tend to reduce water consumption by only a little, and that even in the worst cases, the crunch is disproportionately shouldered by the poor. In the string of droughts that plagued California during the 1980s, for example, doubling the price of water drove household consumption down by a third, but households earning less than $20,000 cut their consumption by half, while households earning more than $100,000 reduced use by only 10 percent.
In fact, critics say, private water companies usually have very little incentive to encourage conservation; after all, when water use falls, revenue declines. In 2005 a second Bolivian riot erupted when another private water company raised rates beyond what average people could afford. The company had dutifully expanded the city’s water system to several poor neighborhoods outside the city. But the villagers there, accustomed to life without taps, were obsessive water conservers and hadn’t used enough water to make the investment profitable.
The biggest winners of a sophisticated water market are likely to be the very few water-rich regions of the global north that can profitably move massive quantities across huge distances. Russian entrepreneurs want to sell Siberian water to China; Canadian and American ones are vying to sell Canadian water to the Southwestern U.S. So far, such bulk transfers have been impeded by the high cost of tanker ships. Now, thanks to the global recession, the tankers’ rates have dropped significantly. If the Sitka plan succeeds, other water-rich cities may soon follow.
But in between the countries that will profit from the freshwater crisis, and those that will buy their way out of it, are the countries that have neither water to sell nor money with which to buy it. In fact, if there’s one thing water has in common with oil, it’s that people will go to war over it. Already, Pakistan has accused India of diverting too much water from rivers running off the Himalayas; India, in turn, is complaining that China’s colossal diversion of rivers and aquifers near the countries’ shared border will deprive it of its fair share; and Jordan and Syria are bickering over access to flows from a dam the two countries built together.
So what do we do? On the one hand, most of the world views water as a basic human right (the U.N. General Assembly voted unanimously to affirm it as such this July). On the other, it’s becoming so expensive to obtain and supply that most governments cannot afford to shoulder the cost alone. By themselves, markets will never be able to balance these competing realities. That means state and federal governments will have to play a stronger role in managing freshwater resources. In the U.S., investing as much money in water infrastructure as the federal government has invested in other public-works projects would not only create jobs but also alleviate some of the financial pressure that has sent so many municipal governments running to private industry. That is not to say that industry doesn’t also have a role to play. With the right incentives, it can develop and supply the technology needed to make water delivery more cost-effective and environmentally sound. Ultimately both public and private entities will have to work together. And soon. Unless we manage our water better now, we will run out. When that happens, no pricing or management scheme in the world will save us.