Younger Dryas deep freeze came about in just a single year in northern Europe

"Harsh Climate Change Once Fell Swiftly"

by Michael Reilly, Discovery News, August 1, 2008

It's one of the most dramatic examples of climate change in Earth's history, and scientists now say it happened almost entirely in one year's time.

Thirteen thousands years ago, Europe was much like it is today -- cool but temperate, with great forests carpeting the land. Ice sheets still nibbled at Finland and Sweden, but for much of the continent the last Ice Age was a distant memory.

Suddenly, the climate went haywire. Warm Gulf Stream currents that brought heat from the equator up toward the pole began to fail. Temperatures plummeted 34 °C, and stayed that way for a millennium.

Now scientists believe they've pinpointed the exact time the northern hemisphere was plunged back into a deep freeze. Examining sediments preserved at the bottom of a remote lake in western Germany, they found that what's known as the Younger Dryas cold period took just a year to sweep across the continent, starting in the autumn, 12,679 years ago.

Led by Achim Brauer of the German Research Center for Geosciences in Potsdam, Germany, the team believes such a quick, profound change in climate could only have been brought about by a shift in winds across the northern hemisphere.

Today prevailing winds in the northern hemisphere above the tropics tend to blow from the southwest to the northeast. Air that flows over Texas soon crosses the Atlantic and winds up over Norway.

As it travels the air passes over the Gulf Stream, a warm ribbon of water pouring northward from the tropics. The balmy air brings heat to Europe, which otherwise would be chilly.

The same was probably true just before the Yonger Dryas set in. But as the vast Ice Age glaciers retreated, their melt water flowed into the northern reaches of the Atlantic Ocean. The injection of fresh water made the sea easier to freeze, and a new skin of ice began advancing south.

The warm conveyor belt of Gulf Stream waters soon ebbed to a trickle. And as the sea ice advanced, the winds shifted into a west-east pattern. Within a year the breezes that warmed Europe had vanished.

"The Younger Dryas continues to surprise us in providing a message as to how quickly climate change can occur," said Daniel Sigman of Princeton University in N.J. Sigman is a co-author on the study, which appears today in the journal Nature Geoscience.

"The hypothesis on this paper is I think a very nice one," Richard Alley of Pennsylvania State University said. Winds tend to blow parallel to temperature gradients, and the gradient between sea ice and open water can be very sharp, up to 40 °C.

The sea ice border probably extended in a rough west to east direction, and the winds would've followed it, bringing cold air to much of Europe.

"You can think of it as a front pushing down across Germany," Alley said. "Winds go where something's pushing them hard. A steep temperature gradient along the edge of sea ice would push hard in an east-west direction."

http://dsc.discovery.com/news/2008/08/01/abrupt-climate-change.html

NASA: Planetary Waves Break Ozone Holes

Planetary Waves Break Ozone Holes by Patrick L. Barry and Tony Phillips

Huge planet-girdling atmospheric waves suppress ozone holes over Earth's northern hemisphere.


Most of the world's ozone-destroying pollutants come from the northern half of our planet. Yet Earth's yawning ozone hole straddles the south pole -- not the north.

Why? New research confirms what scientists have long thought: Giant atmospheric waves spawned by land features such as the Himalayas damp the formation of a northern ozone hole and, as a result, Arctic cities remain safe from unwelcome doses of solar ultraviolet radiation -- at least for now. Researchers caution that climate change could undo the work of those waves and make Arctic ozone holes more common in the future.

Above: The towering Dhaulagiri Range of the Himalayas in central Nepal (shown here in a photo from the International Space Station) is a source of planet-girdling atmospheric waves that warm the stratosphere. [more]

Small ozone holes have in fact formed over the Arctic before; the spring of 1997 is a recent example. But such events are the exception rather than the rule. The chemistry of ozone destruction requires very cold air temperatures in the stratosphere, and the Arctic stratosphere just isn't as cold as its Antarctic counterpart.

The north-south difference is an indirect result of the way land is distributed around Earth -- that is, unevenly. Most of our planet's land and its highest mountains are in the northern hemisphere.

High mountains and land-sea boundaries combine to generate vast undulations in the atmosphere called "planetary-scale waves," or "long waves," which act to heat polar air. Planetary-scale waves are so large that some of them wrap around the whole Earth! Unlike water waves, which displace the water up and down, planetary waves displace air north and south as they travel around our planet. They form in the troposphere (the lowest part of the atmosphere) and propagate upward, transferring their energy to the stratosphere.

Stronger planetary waves in the northern hemisphere warm the Arctic stratosphere and suppress ozone destruction. Land forms in the southern hemisphere also produce planetary waves, but they tend to be weaker because there are fewer tall mountain ranges and more open ocean around Antarctica


Above: In years when planetary waves (or "long waves") in the Northern Hemisphere are unusually weak, an ozone hole can form over the Arctic. Blue and purple indicate regions of low stratospheric ozone.

"The Himalayan plateau is a terrific forcing function for these waves in the north," says Paul Newman, an atmospheric physicist at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center. "If you didn't have the Himalayas, the stratosphere over the Arctic would be much colder than it is."

Newman was the lead author of a paper published last month which presents satellite and meteorological data linking planetary waves to bursts of warming registered in the Arctic -- a connection that scientists long-ago recognized but have only now quantified. (His paper appears in the Sept. 16 issue of Journal of Geophysical Research -- Atmospheres.)

"Typically a wave will warm the polar region by 5o to 10o C," Newman continued. "A 'warm' polar stratosphere is typically in the temperature range -73o to -63o C. Of course, as soon as the wave has dissipated, the polar region begins to cool down again."

Below: Dangerous beauty. Polar stratospheric clouds (PSCs) are common in Antarctica, but a rare sight in the Arctic. They form when temperatures in the stratosphere become extremely cold -- below -78° C. PSCs spell trouble for ozone; tiny ice crystals and droplets within the clouds provide surfaces where CFCs are converted into ozone-destroying molecules. Credit: Lamont Poole, NASA.



Indeed, planetary waves in the northern hemisphere don't always heat the stratosphere enough to prevent substantial ozone destruction. In 1997, for example, the waves were weak because of capricious weather. That triggered a rare springtime ozone hole over the Arctic.

Scientists are concerned that climate change could make such times more common. "If our models of Arctic stratospheric cooling are correct, we would expect lower ozone values across the Arctic during this century," says Newman.

It so happens that stratospheric cooling can be a curious result of global warming. Greenhouse gases, which trap the heat radiating from Earth's surface in the lowest layer of the atmosphere, reduce the heat that reaches the stratosphere. In effect, greenhouse gases cool the stratosphere by insulating it from the warmer Earth below.

Climate changes associated with global warming might also weaken planetary waves -- so say some computer models. The cooling of the stratosphere due to this indirect effect could be more significant than the cooling caused directly by greenhouse gases. However, Newman cautions that this result is still very uncertain because of questions about the fidelity of the computer models.

Another wild card is the changing concentration of ozone-destroying pollutants. The number of CFC molecules in the lower atmosphere, for example, peaked in 1994 and have since declined. Computer simulations show that CFCs in the high stratosphere could return to pre-1980 levels in 30 to 50 years. Because climate change occurs on similar time scales, it's difficult to say which trend would dominate: the cooling of the stratosphere, which would encourage an Arctic ozone hole, or the decline of CFCs, which would suppress it.

Right: Spring is the season when sunlight can trigger the chemistry of stratospheric ozone destruction. But Earth's two poles react differently to the coming of spring. Springtime in Antarctica heralds a large ozone hole, while springtime in the Arctic (six months later) often brings above-average ozone concentrations. Global warming could alter this familiar pattern, though, by chilling the northern stratosphere and producing an ozone hole there as well. [more]

Perhaps only time will tell if far-northern cities will continue to enjoy the good fortune of year-round polar ozone. But many researchers aren't content to wait decades for an answer. With the aid of Earth-watching satellites and ever-improving computer climate models, scientists hope to unravel the puzzle of Arctic ozone before it becomes a problem. After all, one planetary ozone hole is more than enough!

NASA, Marshall Space Flight Center, October 11, 2001
Authors: Patrick L. Barry, Dr. Tony Phillips
Responsible NASA official: John M. Horack Production Editor: Dr. Tony Phillips
Curator: Bryan Walls
Media Relations: Steve Roy
The Science and Technology Directorate at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center sponsors the Science@NASA web sites. The mission of Science@NASA is to help the public understand how exciting NASA research is and to help NASA scientists fulfill their outreach responsibilities.

Web Links

NASA Confirms Arctic Ozone Depletion Trigger -- (NASA/GSFC) Learn more about recent research connecting planetary waves to ozone depletion.

VIDEO: Air Currents in the Polar Stratosphere -- This 552 kB QuickTime animation of Arctic ozone concentrations shows the dynamic nature of air currents in the polar stratosphere. Animation courtesy NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center.

Dawn of a New Ozone Hole -- Science@NASA article: Our planet's Antarctic ozone hole is opening once again as Spring approaches in the southern hemisphere.

Ozone Holes Like it Cold -- What's the connection between colder temperatures and ozone destruction? CFCs don't actually destroy ozone -- first they have to be converted into other forms that can directly attack ozone molecules. Part of this conversion process is catalyzed by the surfaces of tiny crystals and droplets in "polar stratospheric clouds." These clouds only form when temperatures in the stratosphere get extremely cold, below -78° C.

see caption

Above: Dangerous beauty. Polar stratospheric clouds such as these are common in Antarctica, but a rare sight in the Arctic. Such clouds are "breeding grounds" for ozone-destroying molecules.

The Incredible Shrinking Ozone Hole -- Science@NASA article: After reaching record-breaking proportions earlier this year the ozone hole over Antarctica has made a surprisingly hasty retreat.

Peering Into the Ozone Hole -- Science@NASA article: Concentrations of ozone-destroying gases are down, but the Antarctic ozone hole is bigger than ever. It turns out there's more to ozone destruction than just CFCs.

Earth's Fidgeting Climate -- Science@NASA article: Is human activity warming the Earth or do recent signs of climate change signal natural variations? In this feature article, scientists discuss the vexing ambiguities of our planet's complex and unwieldy climate.

NASA's Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer -- Home page for the instrument, which takes daily snapshots of ozone concentrations and UV levels around the Earth.

Ozone and the Atmosphere -- a tutorial on Earth's present day atmosphere, ozone creation and depletion, and the complex interactions under study by scientists worldwide.

Stratospheric Ozone - an electronic textbook

Glossary of ozone-related terms

The Montreal Protocol of 1987 -- Text of The Montreal Protocol, which set provisions for phasing out the use of chemicals determined to hasten ozone destruction.

Link to article: http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2001/ast11oct_1.htm

Jürgen Hubert: More Monckton Manipulations

BLOGGER'S NOTE: I lifted the text below (sans graphs) from Jürgen Hubert's blog post that can be accessed here: http://jhubert.livejournal.com/181274.html

Global Warming - How to Lie with Statistics


First of all, while the used data did show a cooling trend, my linear fit (done with GNUPlot) produced a cooling of:

-0.00156427 °C/month.

Extrapolated for an entire decade, like the author has done, this would translate into:

-0.00156427*12*10 °C/decade = -0.1877124 °C/decade

This is not even half as much as the 0.4 °C/decade the author claimed. But wait, it gets better!


It seems that the author of the article has deliberately started using the 2001-2008 HadCRUT3 data set with one of the hottest months in this period -- which happens to be January 2002 (so he didn't use any 2001 data after all, despite the caption of the graph) -- and then ended using the data with the very coldest month in this period, which was the abnormally cold January 2008:

With such a self-selected data set to confirm his bias, is it any wonder that he got a significant cooling trend?

And what's with using only six years and one month to extrapolate a "cooling per decade" value -- especially when the same data set goes back for far more than a decade and a real value could be easily calculated?

No wonder that this guy apparently doesn't have any peer-reviewed papers to his name -- with such blatant attempts at cooking the data, the reviewers would laugh him out of town.

So what would temperature trends over the last decade actually look like?

Well, I've used the same data set for the period from April 1998 to March 2008 (the last entry), and the following graph is the result...

BLOGGER'S NOTE: More at the link above, but do not fail to miss the update to Arthur Smith's deconstruction of Monckton's faux peer-reviewed paper here:

http://www.altenergyaction.org/Monckton.html

John C. Fyfe et al., Journal of Climate, Vol. 20, No. 21, 2007: Role of Poleward-Intensifying Winds of Southern Ocean Warming

Journal of Climate, Vol. 20, Issue 21 (Nov. 2007) 5391-5400, DOI: 10.1175/2007JCLI1764.1

The Role of Poleward-Intensifying Winds on Southern Ocean Warming

John C. Fyfe and Oleg A. Saenko

Canadian Centre for Climate Modelling and Analysis, Environment Canada, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada

Kirsten Zickfeld, Michael Eby, and Andrew J. Weaver

School of Earth and Ocean Sciences, University of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada

(Manuscript received 8 November 2006, in final form 9 March 2007)

ABSTRACT

Recent analyses of the latest series of climate model simulations suggest that increasing CO2 emissions in the atmosphere are partly responsible for (i) the observed poleward shifting and strengthening of the Southern Hemisphere subpolar westerlies (in association with shifting of the southern annular mode toward a higher index state), and (ii) the observed warming of the subsurface Southern Ocean. Here the role that poleward-intensifying westerlies play in subsurface Southern Ocean warming is explored. To this end a climate model of intermediate complexity was driven separately, and in combination with, time-varying CO2 emissions and time-varying surface winds (derived from the fully coupled climate model simulations mentioned above). Experiments suggest that the combination of the direct radiative effect of CO2 emissions and poleward-intensified winds sets the overall magnitude of Southern Ocean warming, and that the poleward-intensified winds are key in terms of determining its latitudinal structure. In particular, changes in wind stress curl associated with poleward-intensified winds significantly enhance pure CO2-induced subsurface warming around 45°S (through increased downwelling of warm surface water), reduces it at higher latitudes (through increased upwelling of cold deep water), and reduces it at lower latitudes (through decreased downwelling of warm surface water). Experiments also support recent high-resolution ocean model experiments suggesting that enhanced mesoscale eddy activity associated with poleward-intensified winds influences subsurface (and surface) warming. In particular, it is found that increased poleward heat transport associated with increased mesoscale eddy activity enhances the warming south of the Antarctic Circumpolar Current. Finally, a mechanism involving offshore Ekman sea ice transport (modulated by enhanced mesoscale activity) that acts to significantly limit the human-induced high-latitude Southern Hemisphere surface temperature response is reported on.

Link to abstract: http://ams.allenpress.com/perlserv/?request=get-abstract&doi=10.1175%2F2007JCLI1764.1

Global warming speeding up planetary ocean waves

12 June 2007, NewScientist.com news service

Gigantic ocean waves, spanning hundreds of kilometres from crest to crest, have been speeding up thanks to global warming, a new model suggests.

Geophysicists predict that as the ocean surface warms, these so-called planetary waves should speed up. To test this idea, John Fyfe and Oleg Saenko at the University of Victoria in British Columbia, Canada, modelled the changes to ocean wave patterns over the 20th and 21st centuries.

"We were really surprised at how quickly the ocean responded to temperature change," Fyfe says. According to the model, global warming has already increased the speed of the waves, but no one noticed because satellites have not been monitoring their speeds for long enough, he says. The model also shows that by the end of the 21st century, the waves will be a further 20 to 40 per cent faster compared with pre-industrial speeds (Geophysical Research Letters, vol 34, p L10706).

"We knew we'd see an effect, but we didn't think it would be significant for at least another two centuries," Fyfe says. The faster planetary waves will have an effect on global weather, he adds.

From issue 2607 of New Scientist magazine, 12 June 2007, page 23.

Link to article: http://environment.newscientist.com/article/mg19426075.400-global-warming-is-speeding-up-ocean-waves.html

Thomas L. Friedman: The Iceman Cometh

Link to original article: http://www.gopachy.com/forum/comments.php?DiscussionID=26745

By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN, August 3, 2008

Greenland Ice Sheet, 77 degrees 45 minutes N. latitude, 51 degrees 6 minutes W. longitude.

Jorgen Peder Steffensen made me an offer I couldn’t refuse: “If you come to Copenhagen, I will show you a Christmas snow — a real Christmas snow, the snow that fell between 1 B.C. and 1 A.D.”

Now that’s an offer you don’t get every day! But then I don’t go to the Arctic Circle every day. “I can also show you a sample of the very last snow that fell right at the end of the last ice age, which was 11,700 years ago,” said Steffensen. Or, he asked me, “How would you like to see the air samples that contain the sulfuric traces of the Mount Vesuvius volcanic eruption” that buried Pompeii in A.D. 79?

Steffensen is an ice specialist and curator of the world’s most comprehensive collection of ice core samples, a kind of atmospheric DNA drilled out of the glaciers of Greenland and now preserved in refrigerated vaults in the Danish capital. The more and deeper scientists can drill the ice, the better the picture they can give of the climate in previous eras — and therefore the more we will understand about climate change.

Each layer of ice contains water and air bubbles that were trapped in the snow, which, when analyzed by expert scientists, reveal in great detail the temperature, the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, the amount and origins of volcanic dust, and even the amount of sea salt in the air and therefore how close the glacier was to the ocean.

Imagine for a moment a freezer filled with such revealing ice cubes. Each ice cube represents one year’s atmospheric data beginning 150,000 years ago, which is how far back the current Greenland icecap dates. Well, Steffensen, his wife, Dorthe Dahl-Jensen, both of the Centre for Ice and Climate at the Niels Bohr Institute of the University of Copenhagen, and a team of international experts are assembling precisely that kind of freezer from ice cores drilled here in the far north of Greenland in the Arctic Circle.

I traveled to their newest camp with a group of experts led by Denmark’s minister of climate and energy, Connie Hedegaard, and including Rajendra Pachauri, the chairman of the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which shared last year’s Nobel Peace Prize with Al Gore. We flew in on a U.S. Air Force National Guard C-130, which landed on skis — not wheels — since the landing strip was just a plowed strip of ice and snow.

This is surely one of the most remarkable and isolated research stations in the world. Everywhere you look, you see a perfectly flat expanse of snow and ice stretching to the horizon. In fact, you can see so far in every direction that it feels as though you can see the curvature of the earth. The camp consists of a heated geodesic dome where the scientists eat, a dozen barely heated tents where they (and guests) sleep in insulated sleeping bags and an underground research laboratory, carved out of the ice, where they are installing the drill and ice lab equipment. Over the next three “summers,” they will unearth ice core samples all the way down to Greenland’s bedrock — roughly 1.5 miles, or the equivalent of 150,000 years of accumulated ice layers.

Their objective is to do something never done before: project a complete picture of the Greenland climate, from the ice age that lasted from 200,000 to 130,000 years ago, through the warming period known as the Eemian that lasted from 130,000 to 115,000 years ago, through the last ice age from 115,000 to 11,703 years ago, right up to the present warming period we’ve been in since. (Remember: the Earth is usually an ice ball; the warm interglacial periods are the exceptions.)

Their last drilling project here, which was completed in 2004, focused on the layers 14,500 to 11,000 years ago. That project is already causing a stir in the climate community. In an article just published in the journal Science Express, Dahl-Jensen’s team wrote about how it had discovered from the ice cores that the atmospheric circulation in the Northern Hemisphere over Greenland “changed abruptly” just as the last ice age ended around 11,700 years ago.

It seems to have been driven by a sudden change in monsoons in the tropics. The change was so abrupt that it warmed the Northern Hemisphere over Greenland by 10 degrees Celsius in just 50 years — a dramatic increase.

“It shows that our climate system has the ability to make very abrupt changes all by itself,” said Dahl-Jensen.

Some climate-change deniers would say that this proves that mankind is not important in changing the climate. Climate change experts, like Dahl-Jensen, say it’s not so simple: The climate is always changing, sometimes very abruptly, so the last thing that mankind should be doing is adding its own forcing actions — like pumping unprecedented amounts of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. Because you never know — you never know — what will tip the balance and send us hurdling into another abrupt change ... and into another era.

Greenhouse Earth 40 million years ago with little ice on Antarctica

NASA's Earth Observatory, July 28, 2008

SNAPSHOT OF PAST CLIMATE REVEALS NO ICE IN ANTARCTICA MILLIONS OF YEARS AGO

A snapshot of New Zealand's climate 40 million years ago reveals a greenhouse Earth, with warmer seas and little or no ice in Antarctica, according to research published this week in the journal Geology.

The study suggests that Antarctica at that time was yet to develop extensive ice sheets. Back then, New Zealand was about 1100 km further south, at the same latitude as the southern tip of South America – so was closer to Antarctica – but the researchers found that the water temperature was 23-25 degrees C at the sea surface and 11-13 degrees C at the bottom.

"This is too warm to be the Antarctic water we know today," said Dr Catherine (Cat) Burgess from Cardiff University's School of Earth and Ocean Sciences, and lead-author of the paper. "And the seawater chemistry shows there was little or no ice on the planet."

These new insights come from the chemical analysis of exceptionally well preserved fossils of marine micro-organisms called foraminifers, discovered in marine rocks from New Zealand. The researchers tested the calcium carbonate shells from these fossils, which were found in 40 million-year-old sediments on a cliff face at Hampden Beach, South Island.

"Because the fossils are so well preserved, they provide more accurate temperature records." added Dr Burgess. "Our findings demonstrate that the water temperature these creatures lived in was much warmer than previous records have shown."

"Although we did not measure carbon dioxide, several studies suggest that greenhouse gases forty million years ago were similar to those levels that are forecast for the end of this century and beyond.

Our work provides another piece of evidence that, in a time period with relatively high carbon dioxide levels, temperatures were higher and ice sheets were much smaller and likely to have been completely absent."

The rock sequence from the cliff face covers a time span of 70,000 years and shows cyclical temperature variations with a period of about 18,000 years. The temperature oscillation is likely to be related to the Earth's orbital patterns.

Contact: Cat Burgess, Cardiff University, 07-740-500-722
catherine_burgess99@hotmail.com

Link to article: http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Newsroom/MediaAlerts/2008/2008072827309.html